Day 402: Dust and Shadow

Cover for Dust and ShadowIn Dust and Shadow: An Account of the Ripper Killings by Dr. John H. Watson, Lyndsay Faye combines a great deal of research into the Jack the Ripper killings in 1888 with a vast knowledge of Sherlock Holmes literature to offer an entertaining solution to the crimes. The novel begins nearly 50 years after the events, when Dr. Watson places his narrative of the murders into a safety deposit box on the eve of war.

Inspector Lestrade comes to consult Holmes after the second murder, when police begin to realize the two deaths may be linked. Holmes immediately begins pursuing his usual means of detection–inspecting the body and the scenes of the crimes, trying to find out where the victims were last sighted, questioning the victims’ friends–and he very quickly figures out that another murder is related. He even hires an alert young prostitute, Mary Ann Monk, to make her own enquiries and observations after she identifies the body of her friend, Mrs. Nichols. However, he is soon frustrated by his lack of progress. The only lead Holmes has come across is the story of an elusive sailor, being sought by a friend who thinks he may have been involved in the first murder, that of Mrs. Nichols.

Soon Holmes and Watson have something else to worry about, for a member of the press is printing details of the crimes unknown to but a few. He has been alleging that Holmes himself may be the murderer.

Faye’s novel is atmospheric and absorbing. Its greatest accomplishment, though, is in successfully capturing the narrative style of Doctor Watson, making us believe that this could be a Holmes story. Although I was about 100 pages ahead of Holmes in solving the murder (which would never happen in a real Holmes story), I still found the solution ingenious as well as the reason why the crimes are recorded in history as unsolved (when, of course, Holmes solved them). This novel is a very good first effort. I have Faye’s next book awaiting me in my pile.

7 thoughts on “Day 402: Dust and Shadow

  1. October 2, 2013 / 12:46 pm

    Sounds like a mystery I would LOVE~ atmospheric, historical, clever, well-researched. Thank you for the synopsis which didn’t spoil anything, and the nice conclusion which convinced me that this would be a worthwhile read. Have you discovered Barbara Hambly’s Benjamin January mysteries yet? (A Free Man of Color – first one). Set in New Orleans 1830s.

  2. Cecilia October 3, 2013 / 2:15 pm

    I agree – this sounds great. I love mysteries but I’ve tended to stick to contemporary works. I would love the combination with history.

    • whatmeread October 3, 2013 / 2:19 pm

      I was just noticing today that I seem to have reviewed a lot of historical novels this week. It’s been awhile since I reviewed a contemporary mystery. Not on purpose. I have one that I’ll review in a few days.

      • Cecilia October 3, 2013 / 8:09 pm

        Oh, I love historical novels. I think we fall into certain reading patterns without realizing it. I was checking out my stats on Goodreads, and saw that the oldest book I have read so far this year was published in 2005 or something (well, 1999 now that I have finished Ahab’s Wife), and suddenly I realized how limited I have been. Over the last month or so I’ve taken a strong turn to the past and am now interested in catching up on classics.

      • whatmeread October 4, 2013 / 7:33 am

        I think writing this blog has made me think more about what I’m reading, try to read more quality work, and mix it up a lot more for readers with varied interests. I have always read a lot of certain eras of classics, Victorian novels being the most prevalent, but now I am trying some new things.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.