Review 2005: Rose Nicolson

It’s 1575. Mary Queen of Scots has been ousted from the throne of Scotland in favor of her young son James and a series of regents. This revolution has been mostly a religious one, with Queen Mary a Catholic and James (referred to as Jamie Saxe) being raised Protestant. But there is also a struggle between the Calvinists and milder forms of Protestantism.

This struggle is reflected in the home of young William Fowler, whose father is a Calvinist and whose mother, with contacts in Queen Mary’s court, is French and Catholic. However, William’s father is accidentally killed during a siege on Embra. Now William is off on the Sonsie Quine to school at St. Andrews. On the ship, he meets a red-haired boy who asks to borrow his dirk. This meeting proves fateful, as William finds out years later that the boy is Watt Scott of Buccleuch. (For Dorothy Dunnett readers, I believe this is the grandson of the man of the same name in the Lymond chronicles.)

William has an affinity for poetry, and at school he befriends another scholar, Tom Nicolson. He struggles within himself over the religious issue as he feels pressure to commit one way or the other. He also falls in love with Rose Nicolson, Tom’s beautiful sister, a fisher girl with a remarkable mind.

As the King gets older, the Catholics and Protestants compete to control him. The country remains Protestant with the Calvinists gaining power while the Catholic side gains strength at court with the arrival of a favorite from France.

As he approaches graduation, William wants to marry Rose, but she is betrothed to a fisherman with the influence to protect her. She needs this protection because her remarks have been misunderstood as evidence of witchcraft.

William, despite himself, is forced closer to deciding between the two religions and finally decides that Protestantism is the least bad alternative. He also meets Scott again and is drawn into political intrigue.

This is not dry stuff. Greig is great at depicting the realities of living in this difficult time and place. I was fascinated from page one. This novel became part of my Walter Scott prize project by getting on the shortlist, but being a fan of Greig, I had already read it.

Related Posts

Fair Helen

The Ringed Castle

When They Lay Bare

11 thoughts on “Review 2005: Rose Nicolson

  1. Helen August 8, 2022 / 1:08 pm

    I loved this and was sorry it didn’t win this year’s Walter Scott Prize. Andrew Greig writes so beautifully and really brings this period of history to life!

    • whatmeread August 8, 2022 / 2:10 pm

      I thought it was very good, too. I haven’t read the winner yet.

  2. FictionFan August 8, 2022 / 7:13 pm

    This is one of my favourite novels of the year so far, and in fact one of my favourite Scottish novels of all time! Greig is such a good writer, and in this one he’s writing about the period of history that probably interests me most. Glad you enjoyed it too!

    • whatmeread August 9, 2022 / 12:33 am

      Yes, I did. Have you read his Fair Helen? I loved that one.

      • FictionFan August 9, 2022 / 6:56 pm

        I haven’t but I added it to my wishlist when you and Helen both recommended it when I reviewed this one.

      • whatmeread August 9, 2022 / 7:02 pm

        It’s a little more experimental.

      • FictionFan August 9, 2022 / 7:25 pm


  3. piningforthewest August 11, 2022 / 4:05 pm

    I really liked this one too and of course the setting is very local to me. I also really enjoyed the winner of the Scott prize and I’m not sure which one I preferred.

    • whatmeread August 11, 2022 / 4:13 pm

      I haven’t read the winner yet. There are two I will probably have to buy, because they’re not available around here.

  4. Marg September 17, 2022 / 1:47 am

    I think that I need to make myself a project for reading the Walter Scott prize lists next year!

    Thanks for sharing this review with the Historical Fiction Reading Challenge.

    • whatmeread September 17, 2022 / 9:39 am

      I’ve discovered lots of good books on their shortlist.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.