Review 1846: Classics Club Spin Book! The Dead Secret

The latest Classics Club Spin ended up with The Dead Secret as the book I should read. It is Wilkie Collins’ first full-length novel but unfortunately not his best.

Mrs. Treverton is on her deathbed at Porthgenna Tower, but she has a secret. She wants to disclose it to her husband but can’t bring herself to do it. So, she forces her maid, Sarah Leeson, to write it down. She makes Sarah promise not to destroy the confession or remove it from the house, but she dies before she can make her promise to give it to her husband. So, Sarah hides it in a ruined wing of the house and then flees.

Fifteen or sixteen years later, Mrs. Treverton’s daughter Rosamond is a young wife. She and her blind husband, Leonard Frankland, are on their way to Cornwall to take up residence at Porthgenna Tower, where Rosamond has not lived since she was five. They intend to renovate the house, including the ruined north wing, but they have had to stop their journey because Rosamond has gone into premature labor.

The local doctor, in seeking a nurse for the new mother and son, consults a householder only to have her housekeeper, Mrs. Jazeph, unexpectedly volunteer to do it herself. However, Mrs. Jazeph’s odd behavior that evening causes her to be dismissed. Before leaving, she tells Rosamond to stay out of the Myrtle Room.

With a ruined old mansion on the coast of Cornwall that is possibly haunted and a secret too awful to tell, this novel promises to be all that a sensation novel should be. However, Collins is clearly learning here, for this novel is dripping with sentimentality and soppiness. Moreover, the behavior of the maid (it’s not hard to guess who she is) is so exaggerated that I could hardly stand to read about her at times. Collins took Dickens for his model, and Rosamond is a typical type for Dickens—sweet, a little foolish at times, loving, needing the guidance of her morally correct husband. Without having spent enough time with Sarah for us to care much for her—in fact, at times her behavior is extremely irritating—he spends too long a time with a supposedly heart-rending scene.

The secret isn’t very hard to guess, nor are the events of the plot difficult to predict. This isn’t a terrible novel, but Collins has written better ones.

Related Posts

The Haunted Hotel

Hide and Seek

The Moonstone

8 thoughts on “Review 1846: Classics Club Spin Book! The Dead Secret

  1. FictionFan April 28, 2022 / 8:00 pm

    What a pity, because the premise sounds as if it could have been great!

    • whatmeread April 29, 2022 / 2:07 am

      It was okay. Maybe if it wasn’t so easy to guess everything.

  2. Helen April 29, 2022 / 2:09 pm

    I read this years ago, along with a lot of other Wilkie Collins books. I can’t remember it very well now, but I agree that it’s not one of his best and not one that I’ve ever felt tempted to re-read.

    • whatmeread April 29, 2022 / 6:49 pm

      No, I can see why not, although it’s not horrible, it’s just predictable.

  3. Anne Bennett May 3, 2022 / 12:56 pm

    I’ve only read The Woman in White by Collins and thought it was very good. Moonstone is still on my Classics list. Here is my Classics Club Spin THE SECRET GARDEN

    • whatmeread May 3, 2022 / 3:14 pm

      The Moonstone is my favorite Collins so far.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.