Review 1455: City of Girls

So far, it’s hard to predict what Elizabeth Gilbert will write from one novel to the next. I read Eat, Pray, Love reluctantly, because it was so popular and I resisted reading a memoir by someone so young. But I loved it for its style and humor. The Signature of All Things was an enthralling 19th century story about the life of an unusual woman.

In City of Girls, Gilbert re-creates 20th century Manhattan, beginning in 1940. Vivian Morris is a heedless Vassar dropout with no idea what she wants to do and no inclination to do anything. Her status-conscious parents finally ship her off to her Aunt Peg in New York. Peg is the owner of a crumbling old theater in Hell’s Kitchen that puts on brainless entertainment for working class clientele.

Vivian begins a life of drunken nights running around town with the theater’s chorus girls and sleeping with just about anyone and days making costumes for the shows. For Vivian’s talent is sewing.

In the four-story building where the theater is located live Aunt Peg and her partner Olive as well as a motley crew of chorus girls, musicians, and others from the shows. Vivian is delighted to be given the apartment of Aunt Peg’s husband, the debonair Billy Buell, who hasn’t lived there in years. But things change after Peg offers a home to the famous British actress, Edna Parker Watson, whose home was destroyed in the Blitz. Peg decides to stage a good production for Edna, and Billy arrives to help write it.

The show is a success, but shortly thereafter, Vivian takes a fall because of her own foolishness. She ends up returning to her parents’ home in disgrace.

So far, the book was of a piece, even if I didn’t find Vivian a particularly interesting or sympathetic character. But that’s just the first half of the book. During the second half, when a wiser Vivian returns to New York to help out her aunt during the war and proceeding for the next 30 years, I began to wonder what the heck the book was about. It just seems to meander around a lot before coming to an admittedly poignant point.

The conceit employed by the novel is that the entire long novel is a letter to a woman answering her long-ago question of how Vivian knew her father. I think this first-person narrative is a weakness, because I can’t imagine someone writing some of this stuff to anyone, let alone a near stranger. Further, the second half of the novel seems like a different, less purposeful book.

It sounds like I disliked this book. I didn’t, I just feel it has problems, and I never warmed to Vivian.

Related Posts

The Signature of All Things

Lucky Us

Manhattan Beach

10 thoughts on “Review 1455: City of Girls

  1. katknit January 1, 2020 / 8:38 pm

    I always find Elizabeth Gilbert extremely annoying.

  2. Shannon January 2, 2020 / 12:49 pm

    I had the same reaction to Gilbert publishing this book, thinking, What will this woman get up to next, haha. Sounds like it had some pros and cons for you. I may give it a whirl.

    • whatmeread January 2, 2020 / 2:50 pm

      Yeah, I didn’t think it was as absorbing as her other books.

  3. Cynthia C January 4, 2020 / 8:15 am

    The middles of books are the hardest for writers, and many stories seem to lose their way there. I felt Eat, Pray, Love was very interesting but also a little uneven. I enjoyed reading it but wasn’t moved to seek out more yet by Gilbert. If I were her peer in age, I probably would.

    • whatmeread January 4, 2020 / 9:34 am

      I’m definitely not her peer group, but The Signature of All Things was really excellent, and I liked her sense of humor in Eat, Pray, Love.

    • whatmeread January 4, 2020 / 9:35 am

      Cynthia, I didn’t realize this was you! I didn’t know you had a blog. I will subscribe!

  4. Davida Chazan January 4, 2020 / 10:30 am

    Well, from what you write her, Vivian doesn’t sound like a very endearing character. That doesn’t turn me on.

  5. Naomi January 23, 2020 / 10:37 am

    I loved The Signature of All Things so much that I’m a little scared to read this one. The Sig of all Things is a hard one to top, though.

    • whatmeread January 23, 2020 / 1:25 pm

      It’s definitely not as good.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.