Review 1338: Eligible

Cover for EligibleSo far, the Austen Project, for which current writers rework Jane Austen’s novels within a modern framework, hasn’t worked for me. I have a theory that the readers who like them are reading mostly for plot, whereas I read Austen for her quick but subtle wit and her precision. Let’s face it, although humor is always in style, these days subtlety is not. Still, I thought I’d give Eligible, Curtis Sittenfeld’s reworking of Pride and Prejudice, a try.

Obviously, some of the dilemmas in the original novel are just not workable in today’s society, a problem that foundered Joanna Trollope’s reworking of Sense and Sensibility. Sittenfeld is wise enough to realize this and has made significant changes to the characters and plot.

Liz Bennett is a magazine writer who lives in New York. She and her sister, Jane, a yoga instructor, have returned to their home town, Cincinnati, to help out after Mr. Bennett’s heart attack. Their help is needed even though their three younger sisters, suffering from failure to launch, are still living at home, because they are doing nothing. Mrs. Bennett, a social climber, is too involved in running a charitable event to take her husband to his doctor’s appointments.

Jane is pushing forty, so she started in vitro fertilization before returning home. Then she meets Chip Bingley at a charity event. Jane and Chip immediately become involved, but Liz has formed a negative impression of Chip’s friend, Fitzwilliam Darcy, because of remarks she overhears at a party.

Liz has been involved for years with Jasper, a man she fell in love with in her early 20’s. Jasper claims he has an open marriage, and he has been seeing Liz on the side. When Jasper hears Liz has met Darcy, he hints at some misbehavior of Darcy’s when the two attended Stanford together.

Of the Austen Project novels I’ve read, this is the most successful rewrite, but the bar is fairly low. Although the dialogue is humorous, it’s not the sparkling dialogue of the original. Kitty and Lydia, for example, are almost unbelievably vulgar and poorly behaved. It’s also hard for me to believe that these days a mother would be pushing marriage after Jane and Chip have only had a few dates.

I was fairly well entertained, though, until the emphasis went to the Eligible reality show. Although I’m sure Sittenfeld had fun with her parody, that’s where I felt the novel lost steam.

Related Posts


Sense & Sensibility

Northanger Abbey


5 thoughts on “Review 1338: Eligible

  1. katknit April 11, 2019 / 7:43 pm

    I like Curtis Sittenfeld, but have to say that this one sounds dreadful…..

    • whatmeread April 12, 2019 / 12:05 am

      That might be putting it a little too strongly. I haven’t read anything else of hers, so I don’t know if I’d like her other books.

  2. Geoff W April 22, 2019 / 8:19 am

    It was alright. The only other one I’ve read so far is Northanger Abbey. It’s hard to judge these in comparison to Austen, but instead to the other Austen inspired fiction. They’re all upper-middle when compared to those. This is pretty standard Sittenfeld, but her other’s are better as they’re standing alone and not being compared to such mountainous classics.

    • whatmeread April 22, 2019 / 10:22 am

      I guess I don’t see the point if they aren’t comparable to Austen. I thought the movie Clueless did a good job of modernizing Austen, however.

      • Geoff W April 22, 2019 / 11:28 am

        Eh – I’ve always felt Clueless did a wonderful job of modernizing the character Emma, but not the book Emma, but that could be because it’s my least favorite of Austen’s novels.

        As for not comparing them, or at least not without giving them a lot of leeway, I think for me that comes from the sheer number of them. There are hundreds (if not thousands) of fan-fiction works about Austen’s works (and the author) and each one of them taps into whatever the author loved/identified with with Austen. It could be the exact opposite of what we as readers identified with/loved or it could be so similar it’s creepy. Given the scope of those that I’ve read they’re all over the place.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.