Day 228: The Night Circus

Cover for The Night CircusIt is the mid-19th century. Prospero the Enchanter raises his daughter Celia Bowen as if she were an apprentice magician, only it is not magic she is working. Continuing an ancient disagreement, Prospero challenges the man in the gray suit to a competition–his daughter against any opponent. So, the man in the gray suit takes a young boy out of an orphanage.

Both children grow up training for this elusive competition, and when they are adults, the man in the gray suit collaborates in creating the Night Circus and sends his protégé Marco to work for its designer. Soon Celia is employed by the circus as an illusionist, and Celia and Marco take up the competition with no understanding of its rules. Celia doesn’t even know who her opponent is.

The Night Circus is a marvelous place, all white and black and gray, constantly growing and changing. It becomes the venue for and creation of the competition.

The Night Circus has been extremely popular, and it seemed like it was right down my alley. However, although it is entertaining enough and is certainly based on an original idea, at some point my interest began flagging.

I think one major problem of the novel is that we are constantly told how wonderful the circus is, but Erin Morgenstern fails to describe it in a compelling way. Descriptions are vague instead of specific enough for readers to imagine a scene. In two or three consecutive pages, for example, I just happened to notice that Morgenstern used the word “elaborate” five or six times with no attempt to describe each object beyond that word. The details she does divulge don’t sound as if they would be that interesting, and frankly, a black, white, and gray circus seems to be the invention of a person more concerned with style than enchantment. An important part of a circus is the vibrancy of color. I felt no sense of wonder, was never surprised or beguiled, and I was occasionally confused, especially concerning the “wonderful coalescence” described in one scene. What does that mean? Although the competition turns out to be about life and death, I also never felt any sense of danger.

Another problem for me is the fable-like quality of the novel, which treats the characters more emblematically than as real people. You feel some sympathy for Celia and Marco, but you don’t know what they are like. Overall, I found the novel mildly disappointing.

5 thoughts on “Day 228: The Night Circus

  1. Claire 'Word by Word' December 27, 2012 / 10:11 am

    It’s true the circus remains something of an enigma, but I found myself imagining my own Ice Garden and other rooms and thinking what great potential it had if someone dared really paint a picture of what it could look like.

    It is also true that we remain at something of a distance from the characters due to the use of the third person narrative perspective, it would have been more engaging perhaps had the author taken on one of the characters and written it from their perspective, but it works again as a device to keep the circus, its collaborators and the magic away from being completely understood by the reader. Ironically, I started out as you ended up but eventually just let go of the need to know more and watched the story unravel from that distance. However the distance stopped me giving it 5 stars, like I did for instance with The Snow Child, a brilliant work.

    • whatmeread December 27, 2012 / 10:31 am

      I will have to try The Snow Child. It sounds interesting.

      • Claire 'Word by Word' December 27, 2012 / 10:33 am

        I hope you do, it is definitely breathtaking, but in a whole different world, that of the wilderness of Alaska. Brilliantly written.

      • whatmeread December 27, 2012 / 10:36 am

        OK. I will try it and look at your web site, too. Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.